2015 Mercedes-Benz E-Class vs. 2015 BMW 5 Series Sylvania OH & Toledo

2015 Mercedes-Benz E-Class

2015 Mercedes-Benz E-Class

2015 BMW 528i Sedan

2015 BMW 5-Series

For years the Mercedes-Benz E-Class and BMW 5 Series have fought tooth and nail for the top spot in the segment, and to this day, the two options remain as the most competitive vehicles in their class. Both offer a wide variety of models and powertrain options including engines that run on gas and engines that run on diesel. With so many options to choose from, determining which of the luxury offerings is superior can be a difficult task, but with a closer look at the capabilities of the 2015 Mercedes-Benz E-Class vs 2015 BMW 5 Series, it’s clear that the option with the three-pointed star holds a bit of an advantage.


Stunning Performance

The number of model and engine options that exist within the E-Class and 5 Series are seemingly endless, but when you look at the base model of each vehicle, you can learn quite a bit. For example, the most standard model of the E-Class comes equipped with a turbocharged 3.5-liter V6 that is capable of producing as much as 302. In a way, the engine sets the stage for the rest of the lineup, which often surpasses the engines found in the similarly-equipped 5 Series models. Take the base model for example. Rather than a V6 like the E-Class, it has a four-cylinder. It comes turbocharged as well, but with two fewer cylinders, it falls short at 245 horsepower, keeping it from performing quite as well.


Despite the fact that the engine displaces more across two additional cylinders, the E-Class is slightly more fuel efficient than the 5 Series—at least when it comes to the highway cycle. At higher, more constant speeds, the base E-Class is able to stretch a gallon of gas for up to 29 miles, which is just over the 27 mpg rating of the inline-four-equipped 5 Series. If you decide to go for the diesel option, which provides added efficiency for both brands, the Mercedes option once again reigns supreme. While the 5 Series is able to achieve an impressive 38 mpg, it is no match for the E250 BlueTEC sedan, which tops out at 42 mpg.

Worth the Price

Even though the capabilities of the E-Class and 5 Series are similar, the Mercedes offering definitely has a slight edge over that of its Bavarian competitor. Because of this, the starting price of the E-Class is a bit higher than the price of the 5 Series. However, with a difference of just roughly $2,000 between the two, there is not much of a gap. One is arguably more capable while the other is more affordable. The decision of which is truly best, of course, is left up to you to decide.

Get Behind the Wheel

If you want to learn more about how these vehicles differ or want to get the full experience of the E-Class and discover all of its benefits for yourself, be sure to get in touch with us here at Vin Devers Autohaus.